Church Leadership: The Sacred Call to Shepherd the Flock

Church Leadership: The Call to Examine and Protect

Peter now turns his attention to a specific group within the church: the elders and shepherds who bear responsibility for leading God’s people. His exhortation is direct and personal—these leaders must examine themselves to ensure they are protecting and feeding the flock as they ought. The stakes are high. As faithful leaders of the church, their responsibility extends beyond administrative duties to spiritual nurture: feeding believers through sound teaching, protecting them by guiding in the ways of the Lord, and preparing their minds for the spiritual battle waged every day (Ephesians 6:12).

This charge wasn’t given lightly, nor does it come from someone speaking from a place of inexperience. Peter writes as “a fellow elder and a witness of the sufferings of Christ”—he speaks with the authority of one who walked with Jesus, witnessed His crucifixion, and experienced His resurrection. Yet notice Peter’s striking humility: he doesn’t wield his apostolic authority or position himself above other elders. Instead, he identifies himself as a “fellow elder,” a co-laborer in the sacred work of shepherding God’s people. This sets the tone for everything that follows—leadership in Christ’s church is fundamentally about humble service, not hierarchical power.

The metaphor of shepherding carries rich meaning throughout Scripture. Just as a shepherd protects sheep from predators, provides pasture for nourishment, guides them to safe paths, and seeks the lost, so spiritual leaders must protect believers from false teaching (Acts 20:28-31), provide sound doctrine for spiritual growth (2 Timothy 4:2), guide them in righteous living (Hebrews 13:7), and pursue those wandering from truth (James 5:19-20). This is not a casual responsibility or mere job description—it’s a sacred trust from the Chief Shepherd Himself, who will one day evaluate how faithfully His appointed shepherds cared for His flock.

Three Dangers Shepherds Must Avoid

Peter urges the church leadership to protect themselves against three common dangers: the danger of laziness and indifference, the danger of seeking dishonest gain, and the danger of trying to dominate and manipulate others (1 Timothy 3:1-7). These three temptations plague church leadership in every generation, and Peter addresses each directly.

First: Serving willingly, not by compulsion. Some leaders serve out of obligation, guilt, or external pressure rather than genuine calling and desire. This produces grudging, resentful ministry that lacks joy and fails to inspire others. True shepherds serve “willingly”—eagerly, gladly, from hearts overflowing with love for Christ and His people (2 Corinthians 9:7). They don’t need to be coerced or constantly motivated; they’re driven by internal conviction that this is their God-given calling. When ministry becomes drudgery rather than delight, leaders must examine whether they’re operating from duty alone or from genuine love.

Second: Leading eagerly, not for dishonest gain. The temptation to use ministry position for personal profit—whether financial gain, social status, or ego gratification—is ancient and persistent. Peter warns against leaders whose primary motivation is what they can get from ministry rather than what they can give (1 Timothy 6:5). This doesn’t mean pastors shouldn’t be compensated (1 Timothy 5:17-18 says they should be), but compensation cannot be the driving motivation. Leaders who are “in it for the money” will inevitably compromise truth when it threatens their income, avoid confrontation that might reduce attendance, and prioritize numerical growth over spiritual health.

Third: Modeling lives, not dominating people. Perhaps the most dangerous is the temptation to “lord over” those entrusted to your care—to dominate, manipulate, control, or use spiritual authority as a weapon rather than a tool for service (1 Peter 5:3). Jesus explicitly warned against this pattern, contrasting worldly leadership that exercises authority over people with kingdom leadership that serves among people (Matthew 20:25-28). Shepherds are not to be tyrants bullying the flock into submission, but examples inviting the flock toward Christlikeness through their own transformed lives.

The Positive Vision: Teaching Based on the Great Shepherd

Instead, shepherds should strive to model their lives and teaching based on godly character and encouraging growth in the church. In the end, faithful leaders will be presented with a crown of glory—imperishable, eternal, and a mark of victorious achievement (1 Corinthians 9:25). This reward isn’t earned by perfect performance but instead is awarded for faithful service. It’s the Chief Shepherd’s commendation: “Well done, good and faithful servant” (Matthew 25:21).

Effective shepherds point constantly to Jesus Christ, the Great Shepherd, as their model and motivation (Hebrews 13:20-21). They teach His Word faithfully, without compromise or distortion. They exemplify godly character in every area of life—their marriages, parenting, business dealings, responses to criticism, handling of conflict, and pursuit of holiness. They encourage spiritual growth not through manipulation or guilt, but through patient teaching, personal example, and genuine care for each individual’s walk with Christ.

This kind of leadership is exhausting. It requires dying to self daily. It means late-night counseling sessions, early-morning prayer times, careful study preparation, difficult confrontations with sin, patient endurance through criticism, and continual self-examination. Yet it’s also profoundly rewarding—not primarily in earthly recognition or comfort, but in seeing lives transformed by the gospel, believers growing in maturity, churches flourishing in health, and eventually receiving the Chief Shepherd’s eternal commendation.

The Eternal Reward Awaiting Faithful Shepherds

Imagine standing before the throne of the One you have served, having led His flock faithfully through trials, temptations, and spiritual battles. Imagine hearing His voice—not disappointment or rebuke, but approval and welcome. Imagine receiving from His hand a crown that represents not your perfection but His faithfulness working through your weakness. This is the hope that sustains faithful leaders: they labor not for human applause (which is fickle) or earthly reward (which is temporary), but for eternal recognition from the Chief Shepherd who sees every sacrifice, every faithful sermon, every patient conversation, every tearful prayer (Hebrews 6:10).

The “crown of glory that does not fade away” contrasts sharply with earthly achievements. Athletic crowns in Peter’s day were made of perishable laurel leaves—impressive for a moment, then withering to nothing. Human accolades fade, positions end, buildings crumble. But the crown Christ awards endures forever. It represents the transformed lives, the believers strengthened, the faith preserved, the truth taught, the love modeled—eternal investments that outlast all earthly accomplishments (1 Corinthians 3:12-15).

Application for All Believers

While Peter addresses elders specifically, these principles apply to every believer in different spheres of influence. Parents shepherd their children. Small group leaders shepherd participants. Mentors shepherd those they disciple. Older believers shepherd younger ones. The specific contexts vary, but the principles remain: serve willingly from love, not reluctantly from obligation; lead for others’ benefit, not personal gain; influence through example, not domination.

And for those who are formal church leaders—elders, pastors, teachers—Peter’s words carry special weight. You bear sacred responsibility for souls entrusted to your care (Hebrews 13:17). You will give account to the Chief Shepherd for how you stewarded His flock. This should create both sobriety (the weight of responsibility) and joy (the privilege of partnership with Christ in His work).

Examine your motives regularly. Are you serving from genuine love or mere duty? Are you pursuing ministry for what you can give or what you can gain? Are you using position to dominate people or empower them toward Christlikeness? Are you pointing people to Jesus or building your own kingdom? These questions require brutal honesty, but they’re essential for faithful shepherding.

The Chief Shepherd’s Return

“When the Chief Shepherd appears…” These words orient all ministry toward Christ’s return. Leaders serve knowing their tenure is temporary, their authority delegated, their work evaluated by One who sees everything (2 Corinthians 5:10). This reality should both humble us and encourage us.

Jesus Christ is the ultimate Shepherd—the model for all who lead, the source of all true authority, the One who laid down His life for the sheep (John 10:11). Every human shepherd is merely representing Him, extending His care, teaching His truth, modeling His character. When Christ returns, He will evaluate not whether leaders built impressive ministries by worldly standards, but whether they faithfully represented Him, taught His Word accurately, loved His people genuinely, and pointed consistently to His glory.

For those serving in leadership who feel weary, overwhelmed, or discouraged—press on. The Chief Shepherd sees your labor. He knows your sacrifice. He will reward your faithfulness. The crown awaits—imperishable, eternal, glorious. And far more than the crown, you’ll hear His voice: “Well done, My good and faithful servant. Enter into the joy of your Master.”

---

Reflection Questions

1. If you’re in church leadership, which of the three dangers Peter warns against (reluctant service, dishonest gain, dominating others) most tempts you? How can you guard against it?
2. Even if you’re not a formal church leader, in what spheres do you influence others (family, workplace, friendships)? How can you apply Peter’s principles of willing service, pure motivation, and leading by example?
3. How does keeping the Chief Shepherd’s return and coming evaluation in mind change your approach to current responsibilities and leadership opportunities?
4. What does it practically look like to “shepherd” rather than “dominate” those under your care or influence? Where might you be using position to control rather than serve?

---

Prayer

Father, thank You for the privilege of serving in Your kingdom, whether as formal leaders or in everyday spheres of influence. We confess the times we’ve served reluctantly rather than willingly, pursued personal gain rather than others’ good, or tried to dominate rather than lovingly shepherd the flock You’ve entrusted to us.

For those in church leadership, grant them Your strength, wisdom, and endurance. Protect them from the unique temptations that come with spiritual authority. Help them lead as Jesus led—with humility, sacrifice, and constant focus on Your glory rather than their own. Give them joy in the work even when it’s exhausting, and shield them from discouragement when results seem slow.

For all of us, help us see the areas where we influence others and steward those opportunities faithfully. Make us examples worth following as we follow Christ. Keep our eyes fixed on the Chief Shepherd’s return and the eternal rewards that await faithful service.

When You appear, may we hear Your approval, receive Your commendation, and enter into the joy prepared for those who served You well. Until that day, help us press on with willing hearts, pure motives, and humble service. In Jesus’ name, Amen.

---

For further study on serving and loving others faithfully, consider the below devotionals:

• Unity Among Believers: The Beauty of Compassionate Love
• The Proverbs 31 Woman: A Portrait of Strength, Wisdom, and Grace

If you’re in need of a discipleship resource to encourage others in their spiritual growth, check out the How to Grow Spiritually guide which walks through practical steps to grow more like Christ, one day at a time.